M A R T Y R I V M
Were Christians ever tortured and killed in the Colosseum?
The answers seems to be no. The original sources on the amphitheatre are
very few, and a connection between Christian martyrdom and the Colosseum still has to be
found, though the Church for many years has credited the story of Christian martyrs
finding death in the arena (something similar happened, but it was in Gallia).
On the subject I prefer to quote the Catholic Encyclopedia on the net. Entry: Colosseum, or ... Coliseum
THE COLISEUM AND THE MARTYRS
Pope St. Pius (1566-72) is said to have recommended persons desirous of obtaining relics to procure some sand from the arena of the Coliseum, which, the pope declared, was impregnated with the blood of martyrs. The opinion of the saintly pontiff, however, does not seem to have been shared by his contemporaries. The practical Sixtus V (1585-90) was only prevented by death from converting the Coliseum into a manufactory of woolen goods.
In 1671 Cardinal Altieri regarded so little the Coliseum as a place consecrated by the blood of Christian martyrs that he authorized its use for bullfights. Nevertheless from the middle of the seventeenth century the conviction attributed to St. Pius V gradually came to be shared by the Romans. A writer named Martinelli, in a work published in 1653, put the Coliseum at the head of a places sacred to the martyrs. Cardinal Carpegna (d. 1679) was accustomed to stop his carriage when passing by the Coliseum and make a commemoration of the martyrs. But it was the act of Cardinal Altieri, referred to above, which indirectly effected a general change of public opinion in this regard. A pious personage, Carlo Tomassi by name, aroused by what he regarded as desecration, published a pamphlet calling attention to the sanctity of the Coliseum and protesting against the intended profanation authorized by Altieri. The pamphlet was so completely successful that four years later, the jubilee year of 1675, the exterior arcades were closed by order of Clement X; from this time the Coliseum became a sanctuary.
At the instance of St. Leonard of Port Maurice, Benedict XIV (1740-58) erected Stations of the Cross in the Coliseum, which remained until February, 1874, when they were removed by order of Commendatore Rosa. St. Benedict Joseph Labre (d. 1783) passed a life of austere devotion, living on alms, within the walls of the Coliseum. "Pius VII in 1805, Leo XII in 1825, Gregory XVI in 1845, and Pius IX in 1852, contributed liberally to save the amphitheatre from further degradation, by supporting the fallen portions with great buttresses" (Lanciani). Thus at a moment when the Coliseum stood in grave danger of demolition it was saved by the pious belief which placed it in the category of monuments dearest to Christians, the monuments of the early martyrs. Yet, after an exhaustive examination of the documents in the case, the learned Bollandist, Father Delehave, S.J., arrives at the conclusion that there are no historical grounds for so regarding it (op. cit.). In the Middle Ages, for example, when the sanctuaries of the martyrs were looked upon with so great veneration, the Coliseum was completely neglected; its name never occurs in the itineraries, or guide-books, compiler for the use of pilgrims to the Eternal City. The "Mirabilia Romae", the first manuscripts of which date from the twelfth century, cites among the places mentioned in the "Passions" of the martyrs the Circus Flaminius ad pontem Judaeorum, but in this sense makes no allusion to the Coliseum. We have seen how for more than a century it served as a stronghold of the Frangipani family; such a desecration would have been impossible had it been popularly regarded as a shrine consecrated by the blood, not merely of innumerable martyrs, but even of one hero of the Faith. The intervention of Eugenius IV was based altogether on patriotism; as an Italian the pope could not look on passively while a great memorial of Rome's past was being destroyed. "Nam demoliri urbis monumenta nihil aliud est quam ipsius urbis et totius orbis excellentiam diminuere."
Thus in the Middle Ages no tradition existed in Rome which associated
the martyrs in any way with the Coliseum; it was only in the seventeenth century and in
the manner indicated, that it came to he regarded with veneration as a scene of early
Christian heroism. Indeed, little attention was paid by the Christians of the first age to
the actual place of a martyr's sufferings; the sand stained with his blood was, when
possible gathered up and treasured as a precious relic, but that was all. The devotion of
the Christian body centred wholly around the place where the martyr was interred. Father
Delehaye calls attention to the fact that although we know from trust-worthy historical
sources of the execution of Christians in the garden of Nero, yet popular tradition
preserved no recollection of all event so memorable (op. cit., 37). The Acts of Roman
Martyrs, it is true, contain indications as to the places where various martyrs suffered:
in amphitheatro, in Tellure, etc. But these Acts are often merely pious legends of the
fifth, sixth, and following centuries built up by unknown writers on a feast reliable
historical facts. The decree formerly attributed to Pope Gelasius (492-96) bears witness
to the slight consideration in which this class of literature was held in the Roman
Church; to read it in the churches was forbidden, and it was attributed to unknown
writers, wholly unqualified for their self-imposed task (secundum antiquam
consuetudinem, leguntur, quia et eorum qui conscripsere nomina penitus ignorantur, et ab
infidelibus et idiotis superflua aut minus apta quam rei ordo fuerit esse putantur.--
Thiel. Epist. Rom. Pont., I, 458).
The evidence, therefore, which we possess in the Roman Acts in favour of certain martyrs suffering in the Coliseum is, for these reasons among others, regarded by Father Delehaye as inconclusive. He does not deny that there may have been martyrs who suffered in the Coliseum, but we know nothing on the subject one way or the other. (Je ne veux pas nier qu'il y ait eu des martyrs de l'amphithéâtre Flavien; mais nous ne savons pas non plus s'il y en a eu, et en tout cas leurs noms nous sont inconnus.--Op. cit., 37.) It is, of course, probable enough that some of the Christians condemned ad bestias suffered in the Coliseum, but there is just as rnuch reason to suppose that they met their death in one of the other places dedicated to the cruel amusements of imperial Rome; for instance, in the Circus Flaminius, the Gaianum, the Circus of Hadrian, the Amphitheatrum Castrense, and the Stadium of Domitian. Even as regards St. Ignatius of Antioch, the evidence that he was martyred in the Coliseum is far from decisive, the terms employed by St. John Chrysostom and Evagrius in reference to this matter convey no precise meaning (Delehaye, op. cit. 43). The same is true of the term used by Theodoret in reference to the death of St. Telemachus, who sacrificed his life to put an end to the bloody spectacles which, as late as the early fifth century, took place in Rome. There is no reason to doubt the fact of the heroic death of St. Telemachus, but there is, on the other hand, no clear proof that its scene was the Coliseum. Theodoret, the only writer who records the incident, says that it happened eis to stadio (in the stadium), a different place from the Coliseum.
MAURICE M. HASSET
Transcribed by Joseph P. Thomas